Elections Watch
Stabroek News
March 26, 2001
Election violence fuelled by baseless rumours -GHRA
Election-related violence targeting Afro-Guyanese, believed to be
responsible in some way for the PPP/Civic election victory, must be
condemned without reservation, the Guyana Human Rights Association
(GHRA) said in a release on Saturday.
Stating that "every Guyanese should consider it a special duty
to promote peace and prevent racial harassment, the GHRA noted that
all the recent incidents of violence were fuelled by baseless rumours
and instigators who encouraged young people to set fires and break
bottles.
PPP/Civic parliamentarian Odinga Lumumba, PNC REFORM Commissioner
Haslyn Parris, and GAP/WPA party agent, Desmond Trotman - who was
mistaken for a PPP/Civic agent - were the most notable Afro-Guyanese
casualties of the violence, the GHRA said.
Allegations, the release said, have also been made by the PPP/Civic
of attacks on three of its polling agents of Afro-Guyanese descent in
Georgetown. Afro-Guyanese workers from the Elections Commission have
also been singled out for attack.
In the violence, the release said that the fact must not be
overlooked that the majority of villagers resisted attempts to be
drawn into violent conflict and in a number of cases, protected
Indo-Guyanese who found themselves caught up in the melee. It was
noted that Afro-Guyanese at Plaisance restrained others from doing
violence to a group of Indo-Guyanese construction workers on a school
site and from destroying a vehicle owned by an Indo-Guyanese.
A strategy, the GHRA said is needed to help villagers on the ground
to resist the destabilising influence of rumours.
However, the release said that rumours will continue to be virulent
as long as some private media are allowed to persist in sewing fear
and hatred and because state media information is not trusted.
The GHRA said that while it was heartening that so many East Coast
villagers resisted the troublemakers, they must be supported and
strengthened by those in authority.
The release said religious and other community organisations should
become networks to share accurate information in order to put a stop
to rumours. Teachers and those in a position to influence young people
must find ways of helping them to resist manipulation.
The GHRA said that from what it had been able to ascertain, rumours
from outside the village about election results fuelled initial
disturbances of the peace in Buxton on Wednesday. These escalated into
more serious acts of violence and vandalism when the police intervened
in a manner some reports suggest was over-reactive.
According to the GHRA young men and young women were used extensively
by instigators to set fires and throw stones at the police. In one
village, the release said that a mother supervised her two teen-aged
sons in breaking bottles on the Railway Embankment Road.
The GHRA also contended that outside elements first instigated locals
to break bottles, burn tyres and block highways. It was also rumoured
that Buxton people were marching to beat up Plaisance people who voted
for the PPP/Civic. Similar rumours also circulated in Beterverwagting.
The GHRA said that ordinary citizens were generally indignant at
their villages being targeted for political violence by outside
elements. These villages, both Indo and Afro-Guyanese have to contend
with rising levels of unemployment and drop-outs involved with drugs
and alcohol who are especially vulnerable to outside provocation.
While the main protest was played out in the Afro-Guyanese
communities, Indo-Guyanese communities were also caught up in the fear
of violence and few slept. (Back to top)
Islamic group
calls on stakeholders to accept poll results
The Central Islamic Organisation of Guyana (CIOG) is appealing to
all stakeholders to accept the results of the general and regional
elections so that the task of nation-building can proceed.
In a release, the CIOG also called on "all the leaders of
political parties and the Guyanese nation to respect the will of the
people as evidenced by the election".
According to the CIOG, the Elections Commission did an excellent job
in view of the human, material and time constraints under which it was
forced to operate.
Commending the Chairman of the Elections Commission, Major General
(retd) Joe Singh, the Commissioners and the staff of GECOM for
conducting an orderly, peaceful and virtually incident-free elections,
the CIOG also commended the electorate for voting in an orderly and
peaceful manner.
The CIOG noted that the local and international observers have
confirmed that proper procedures were adhered to and the polls met
international benchmarks. Based on these, the CIOG said it accepts the
results of the elections and was satisfied with the transparency and
the integrity of the process. (Back to top)
Closed or opened? One might wonder
while driving pass the Kwality Supercentre on Regent Street if it is
open for business or closed because of the metal barriers erected in
front of the building. Well stop wondering, it is open and has been
open since last week Monday even though the barriers were there. The
supercentre like many other businesses took precautionary measures in
light of the election season. Only one of its doors was open
yesterday. (Lawrence Fanfair photo)
PNC/R charges of
padded roll unfounded - Joe Singh
The PNC REFORM (PNC/R) continues to allege that there was padding of
the voters list for the March 19 elections but it is an allegation
that Elections Commission chairman, Maj Gen (rtd) Joe Singh believes
is unfounded.
In a statement issued on Saturday night, the PNC/R said that among
factors which affected the elections according to its analysis was the
"size of the voters list (440,185) and the obvious padding
notwithstanding (the Guyana Elections Commission) GECOM's efforts to
provide an acceptable list."
It said that it supports the call by the European Union Long Term
Observer Group in its March 21, 2001 statement "for a thorough
external audit of the computer software and systems" of the
Commission's Information Systems Department.
The Commission has already initiated an independent audit of the
Official List of Electors (OLE) - the final voters list - and the
database from which it was generated.
Singh told Stabroek News yesterday that until the PNC REFORM can
adduce evidence to the contrary, he cannot accept that the list was
padded. He stressed that the 440,185 names on the list were those
persons who were photographed under the scrutiny of agents from the
PNC REFORM and the other parties which contested the election.
The PNC/R also restated its concern about the 439,000 persons
photographed and the number of persons omitted from the list in the
light of the fact that a number of cards issued "were found to
have photographs taken since (the) 1996 registration (exercise)".
The statement noted that "the GECOM had given (the) assurance
that all old photographs would be destroyed and only new photographs
would be used on National ID cards."
"The PNC/R feels that the flaws identified above affected the
actual results of the elections. Further the manner of the dislocation
of electors from their original addresses and other flaws leave no
doubt that there was deliberate manipulation of the voters list
intended to disenfranchise its supporters and enhance the chances of
the PPP/C." This particular claim by the PNC/R has been denied in
many quarters and it has been pointed out that the omissions were
systematic and occurred in all parts of the country.
President Bharrat Jagdeo said at a press conference on Friday that
his party's supporters were also affected particularly those outside
Georgetown.
Among the other flaws identified by the PNC/R are the dislocation of
registrants on the OLE and its Addendum as well as the removal of
registrants previously listed on the Revised Voters List from the OLE
and Addendum and persons with National ID Cards not listed on the OLE
or the Addendum.
In a memorandum to Singh on March 22, which Stabroek News has seen,
the Commission's Information Systems Department (ISD) suggested that
the dislocation of voters on the OLE and Addendum could have been due
to the phenomenon referred to as "registrar contention".
It said this phenomenon is the result of "two registrars
continually requesting that the ISD edit a registrant's records to
transfer him/her to their division."
The memorandum said that both the ISD/TOC (Technical Oversight
Committee) "believe that this can be caused even by two
conscientious registrars, each firmly believing that he/she is
perfectly correct - the former say, because the registrant has taken a
photo in their subdivision, and the latter because the registrant has
signed a Form 5 in their presence requesting a transfer to their
division."
"At each iteration of the process, one or the other of these
registrars, not seeing the registrant listed in the subdivision they
control, requests a transfer in of the registrant".
The memorandum added that the ISD/TOC's initial examination of this
issue showed that there were a number of persons who had more than one
transfer effected, and this along with our observations of the
'factory-floor' during processing in the main computer room have led
it to that belief.
"We note in hindsight that if the Commission had not allowed the
relaxation of the standard recommended by ISD and TOC (i.e. that ONLY
signed Form 5s and other registrant-signed documents be used as source
documents), this type of happenstance should not have occurred. ISD
and TOC are aware that the Commission allowed the use of Memoranda and
other evidence to guide the process in an effort to cater to as many
citizens as possible."
In its explanation of the omission of persons from the OLE after
having been listed on the Revised Voters List (RVL) and the National
Register of Registrants (NRR) which preceded it, the memo noted that
the NRR, the Preliminary Voters List and the RVL required only "that
a registrant be listed. That is if the registrant was actually listed
in a sub-division that did not exist (hanging divisions), this was not
a problem."
"The RVL and predecessors served as drafts for registrants (or
registrars) to correct issues such as imprecise location,"
according to the ISD memorandum. It explained that registrants might
be listed imprecisely in a "hanging division" due to an
encoder incorrectly entering the last letter in the real subdivision.
(e.g. a registrant is encoded as living in subdivision 413242 or
413242N when the correct choice would have been 413242B).
The OLE (and Addendum) cannot express non-existent divisions, so
registrants whose records persisted in this state at the time of the
OLE were `removed' from the OLE and the Addendum.
The ISD recalled that it found some 517 persons (who) were left off
the OLE and some 400 of these were rectified as result of the
corrective efforts by itself and the National Registration Centre.
About those persons in possession of National Identification Cards
but left off the OLE, the ISD memo pointed that for expediency the
Commission approved the use of the RVL for printing the new National
Identification cards. As a result it explained that a registrant could
therefore conceivably have a valid card printed and subsequently have
a change to his records made, as requested by a registrar, that
transferred him/her to another location.
It said that the ISD also understands that a registrant's
misapprehension as to where he/she was required to vote also cannot be
ruled out as "many persons were required to vote at locations
other than that where they uplifted their National ID card.
The memorandum said that the department recognised that the
explanations offered were "obviously largely qualitative"
but that it remained "open to scrutiny and interaction with
entities that wish to improve and enhance the current elections
process."
It noted too that "the current manner of collecting and
processing voter data is unwieldy and that alone exposes a registrant
to the risk of some part of the system failing. (Back
to top)
PNC REFORM says it
had seriously mulled pulling out of election
A release from the PNC REFORM issued on Saturday night said that it
had seriously considered withdrawing from the March 19 elections
because of its concerns about the state of the voters list.
The option was considered at a meeting of its central executive
committee on March 18. The meeting was convened following the refusal
by the Elections Commission to make arrangements that would have
allowed those persons in danger of being disenfranchised for one
reason or the other, to exercise their franchise.
The release noted that the assurance given the party by the
Commission on March 11, was not honoured and that "despite the
fact that information was transmitted to the Commission before
E(lection) Day, the Addendum (to the Official List of Electors)failed
to include many of the submissions."
"The anger and frustration of those who were disenfranchised
should therefore be understood."
Stabroek News had reported on March 20 that the PNC REFORM had
considered pulling out of the poll. The official who had spoken to
this newspaper had, however, said that while the option had been on
the table it was not seriously considered. (Back to
top)
Power sharing is
the only answer to violence - GAP/WPA
GAP/WPA is restating its call for the formation of a National
Government.
It has written to President Bharrat Jagdeo and PNC REFORM leader
Desmond Hoyte requesting that they jointly convene a meeting of the
parties that contested the elections along with the major
organisations of civil society to take the idea forward.
A release issued by the two-party alliance which won two seats at the
March 19, elections said that "a National Government will draw on
all of the country's resources and allow all minds to deal with
Guyana's political future, the Constitution, the economy, and the
livelihood, security and safety of our less than a million people."
The GAP/WPA release said that it was continuing to make the call on
which it had campaigned "because in countries like ours, with
deep racial divisions, progress depends on developing a form of
government which shares power among the competing groups."
The release said that in the face of a rapidly deteriorating
situation, "in our opinion there is no time to lose in moving
towards the National Government the country has always needed."
"With people fearing one another and fearing for their peace,
their security their livelihood and the very future of the country, we
are more than convinced that so-called `inclusive government' will
provide only a cosmetic change which will not meet the needs of all of
the people of Guyana."
As a consequence GAP/WPA "therefore recommends cutting the
people's losses and going directly to negotiations about power-sharing
in a National Government. It is the only answer to violence."
It said that a national government means shared power beginning at
Cabinet level and in other executive organs especially between the two
major parties. (Back to top)
Dharmic Sabha
congratulates Jagdeo
The Guyana Hindu Dharmic Sabha has extended congratulations to
President Bharrat Jagdeo on his election as the country's President
and his party's victory at the just concluded general and regional
elections.
The Dharmic Sabha in a release expressed confidence that Jagdeo will
continue with the work he has started towards the development of
Guyana and the fulfilment of his vision for this country.
The release said "it is their prayer that God grant his
excellency the wisdom and strength to lead our country on the path of
peace and progress and that he may enjoy the support and cooperation
of all Guyanese so that he can advance the country further. It is the
wish of the Sabha that all citizens demonstrate togetherness so that
their hopes and expectations can be fulfilled in the shortest possible
time."
The release added that the Dharmic Sabha continues its prayers for
peace and stability in the land so that all may prosper and flourish.