Laws contract breached Cabinet's instructions
-Office of the President
By Patrick Denny
Stabroek News
June 20, 2001
The Office of the President yesterday said that a contract for the
printing of the updated Laws of Guyana, executed by the Ministry of
Legal Affairs on March 15, committed public funds without the
knowledge of Cabinet.
The contract was awarded to New Global Consults Inc which has offices
at 126-03 Liberty Avenue, Richmond Hill, Queens NY. Its principals are
US-based Guyanese.
A release from the Office of the President (OP) yesterday said that
an "Investigation should soon be concluded as to the basis for
the action taken by the Ministry of Legal Affairs in disregard of the
Cabinet Decision CP(2001) 2:1:N. The (OP) statement had been promised
since last week and came in the wake of a series of reports in
Stabroek News on the award of the contract.
The Permanent Secretary, Ganga Persaud signed the contract on behalf
of the Ministry. Contacted for a comment yesterday, Persaud could not
offer one as he said he had not yet seen a copy of the statement by
the Office of the President.
The statement said that the US$220,500 contract resulted from Cabinet
Decision CP(2001) 2:1:N issued on February 13 but that "the
conditions of the contract were not adhered to.
"Specifically, the expected external financing by the IDB
(Inter?American Development Bank) of the US$220,500 expenditure to be
incurred for printing the Volumes was not acquired."
Stabroek News understands that the investigation was being conducted
internally at the Ministry of Legal Affairs and would then be extended
to include the Central Tender Board, the other agency that would be
involved in the award of the contract.
Cabinet Secretary Dr Roger Luncheon had explained that the person
responsible for the execution of contracts at the Ministry is the
Accounting Officer who is the Permanent Secretary. He said that the
rules provided for the Permanent Secretary being surcharged if he is
responsible for overspending.
The contract was awarded to New Global Consults Inc to print 300
ten?set volumes of the Laws of Guyana; 300 CDs on which the updated
laws were recorded and for establishing a website on which the updated
laws would be printed.
Office of the President officials have told Stabroek News that
Cabinet had required that the Ministry of Legal Affairs obtain a "no
objection" statement from the IDB for the sole sourcing of the
contract through which it was to be awarded. Operators in the local
information technology sector had complained via letters to this
newspaper that tenders were not invited from local companies and
questioned the procedure for the award of the contract. They had said
that the contract could have been executed by local companies.
Sources had said that the government's lawyers were looking at the
possibility of repudiating the contract. However, legal sources have
told Stabroek News that the Permanent Secretary who signed the
contract could be presumed to have the authority to do so. In such a
case, they said it would be difficult, if at all, for the government
to get out of it. Another complication is that the volumes are to be
delivered by monthend.
When first approached by Stabroek News, the ministry had said that
the US$220,500 contract was an IDB contract but after the report
appeared the ministry corrected itself and stated that it was being
funded by the Guyana government. The ministry also that the contract
was entered into on the basis of a Cabinet decision.
However, when contacted Dr Luncheon had said that it was being funded
by the IDB. Stabroek News contacted the IDB which flatly denied that
it had provided any funding for the project.
Stabroek News understands too from sources at the Ministry of Finance
that New Global Consults had lost out on a US$150,600 contract funded
by the IDB to US law firm Foley, Hoag and Eliot with which government
lobbyist Paul Reichler is associated for improving the legal framework
for property rights.
These sources told Stabroek News that New Global Consults Inc was
rated No 2 and that no local firm tendered for the contract.
Stabroek News has telephoned the company at its Richmond Hill,
Queens, New York address but has been unable to speak to any of its
officers.